(Click here for a recap of SVT #16, Second Best)
Here’s a good title for Women’s History Month! In Boys Against Girls, the boys are INDEED against girls, and the girls are against being treated like second-class citizens at the hands of their idiotic and impressionable classmates. One such classmate is on the cover with Jessica. I would guess that’s Jerry McAllister or Charlie Cashman, because they are the 2 biggest assholes in this book, other than the adults.

Truth be told, the examples of sexism in this book are so outlandish that it scared me a bit—everything is kept pretty tame in the Twins books because of the younger audience, so if these examples were meant to show “sexism lite” for kids in 1988, well, then…wow, that’s FUCKED, and we’ve come a long way.
Quick personal note before we begin—in fifth grade, I was a staunch supporter of my female classmates’ assertion that our new gym teacher was sexist. He gave all the boys in our grade “Es” (my school’s “A” equivalent) and all the girls “Gs” (equivalent for “B”). There were 2 exceptions on either side, I believe. We started a petition saying he was sexist and a teacher’s aide or somebody found it before we were ready to turn it in. As we all stood lined up to go back inside after recess, he and bunch of female teachers stood there and LAUGHED AT IT. It was quite appalling, actually.
Looking back, I know 2 things for sure. 1) If anything like this happened now, it would be approached respectfully. Maybe not seriously, but respectfully. I think that’s progress. 2) There’s no way I deserved an E in Gym.
Anyway! Let’s get on with it! The twins’ homeroom teacher has fled Sweet Valley (no doubt because she has a secret past that’s catching up with her) and their new teacher is A MAN. This is big news. His name is Mr. Davis and he’s a piece of shit. He immediately rearranges everyone’s seats so that all the boys are on one side of the room and all the girls are on the other. Then he blatantly ignores the girls except to hurl the occasional belittlement in their direction. This includes things like sticking them with classroom chores he deems “appropriate,” like cleaning up after class and watering the plants.
Cleaning up after class? Wtf? What are they doing, arts and crafts? How about everyone cleans up after themselves, because you know. These people are 12.
The kids fill him in on some homeroom activities. Apparently, each homeroom has a baseball team (again, WTF) and the playoffs are fast approaching. Mr. Davis’ new homeroom is in the playoffs.
“Excellent!” Mr. Davis exclaimed, smiling broadly. “You boys must be terrific ballplayers.”
I guess that’s red flag number 3, after the seating arrangement and the chores.
“Tomorrow we’ve got our homeroom outing to the San Diego Zoo. Elizabeth organized it.”
Mr. Davis looked blank. “Who?”
“Elizabeth Wakefield.”
Mr. Davis can barely compute that there is a female student in the class, let alone one capable of organizing a class trip. (I know it’s not the point, but what HOMEROOM takes a class trip? When I was in school, homeroom was like a place to sit for 5 minutes before school started. I don’t think it was even a thing past the first day of each year.)
Elizabeth tells Mr. Davis about the trip, including the fact that they collected money for admission and lunches.
Mr. Davis counted out some bills and put them in a separate envelope. Then he got up, went to Elizabeth’s desk, and handed her the rest. “You girls buy whatever you need and make sandwiches for lunch.” Then he returned to his desk.
That would be red flag number 4.
Red flag number 5 comes when Mr. Davis asks for suggestions about the exhibits they want to hit and only takes suggestions from the boys.
By the way, Elizabeth says admission to the San Diego Zoo is $2 a person. I know this was a long time ago, but still, that seems cheap. Perhaps they gave her the Wakefield twin discount. Also, I just looked online and adult admission is defined as being 12+ and it costs $62 a person. Just in case you were planning anything.
Red flag number 6 comes when Mr. Davis has a hernia over Elizabeth volunteering to get rid of a spider and he appoints Tom McKay to the task.
The next chapter leads off with the sandwich-making, and Jessica rather awesomely decides to make a special sandwich for Mr. Davis.
She took a piece of bread and spread it with peanut butter and jelly, then she added slices of bologna and cheese. Then she went to the refrigerator and extracted a jar of pickles.
“Jessica!” Amy squealed. “That’s awful!” But, she was grinning as Jessica pulled out a pickle, neatly sliced it, and added it to the mess on the sandwich.
Nora was watching in awe. “That’s the most revolting thing I’ve ever seen.”
Elizabeth gasped. “Jess, you’re not really going to give that to Mr. Davis, are you?”
Jessica stepped back and examined her work critically. “Just one more thing.” She went back to the refrigerator and pulled out a bag of flaked coconut left over from a cake Mrs. Wakefield had baked.
Haha. I miss being 12. Mr. Davis does take a bite out of the sandwich, by the way. He turns green but doesn’t say anything, and I’ll never know why.
After the zoo trip, Mr. Davis passes out poems—one for the boys and one for the girls—that he wants everyone to read before their next homeroom. The boys’ poem is about a soldier fighting in the Revolutionary War. The girls’ poem is about fairies dancing in a garden.
In class, he makes Amy read the poem out loud. It contains lines like, “In my garden every day, the little fairies come and play.” It’s really embarrassing, and Amy rightly tells Mr. Davis the poem is dumb.
Mr. Davis raised his eyebrows. “I felt your poem would be more appropriate for girls.”
I’ve lost count on the red flags, guys.
The next thing for Mr. Davis to screw up is something called the Sixth Grade Follies. Each homeroom is to write and perform a skit. Amy and Nora try to nominate Elizabeth to be the director.
The teacher’s face was stern. “I don’t recall saying anything about an election for director. I’ve already decided to ask Tom McKay to direct the skit.“
Tom clearly doesn’t want to be the director but he doesn’t object. I guess because he’s a man and he feels it’s his duty to fulfill whatever responsibilities are asked of him and then treat whoever he deems responsible with passive aggression for the next several years, until eventually, the relationship cannot be repaired.
Anyway.
Nora tells Mr. Davis that she’s written a skit.
“That’s nice, but the boys said that they’ve already got a skit. Ross, why don’t you tell the rest of the class about it.”
Ross Bradley (Who?!) stood up and waved a few sheets of paper in the air. “I got this from my brother. He’s in college, and his fraternity did this skit. It’s really cool. See, a bunch of guys are in this jungle, trying to capture an ape. Only they can’t, cause the ape’s very strong, and keeps knocking them all down. So all the guys dress up like apes and trick the real ape into following them.”
Oh for the love of John Stamos.
After class, the girls gripe.
“My skit’s much better than Ross’s, Nora said mournfully.
“And I was counting on directing it,” Elizabeth added in the same tone. “I just don’t understand Mr. Davis at all.”
“I do,” Amy said unexpectedly. “I mean, I think Mr. Davis is an outright sexist.”
Nora’s mouth dropped open. “You’re nuts! He’s not even good-looking!”
I expected more from Nora. I’m not sure why, but I did. This is an Ellen Riteman line. And she would have delivered it better.
The twins have all the girls in their homeroom over for chips, pretzels, sodas, and scheming. They decide to start acting the way Mr. Davis believes they are: dumb, silly, and helpless. They all decide to wear their frilliest dresses to school tomorrow and put the plan into action.
Jessica says she can’t feed the gerbils because she’s scared they might bite her. Ellen complains that she can’t water the plants because the watering can is so heavy. They all giggle uncontrollably and talk in squeaky high voices. Mr. Davis’ response to all of this?
“Well, girls will be girls.”
Then they talk about the upcoming softball game. Ross begrudgingly admits that Amy and Nora are 2 of their best hitters.
Mr. Davis frowned. “Amy and Nora? Are you telling me you have girls on this team?” When Ross nodded, Mr. Davis’ frown deepened. “I certainly hope the girls aren’t in key positions.”
“Yeah,” Charlie said. “I don’t know why we let girls on the team in the first place.” Several other boys nodded in agreement.
YIKES.
Game time: the girls throw the game completely and their team loses. Mr. Davis acts like a maniac who had money on it or something.
“That was terrible!” he yelled. “I thought you were supposed to be such a good team! And you were leading! What happened out there?”
“It was those stupid girls,” Charlie said angrily. “We could have won that game easily.”
“Well, you can’t really blame them,” Mr. Davis replied. “That’s the way girls play. The real question is, why are they on the team?”
And that’s that. The girls are taken off the team.
Jessica says they’ve got to amp up their efforts. The next goal is to get Mr. Davis fired, and they have the perfect opportunity to do it that coming Monday, when Mr. Clark will be observing their homeroom.
When Ross (he’s really a star player in this book—is he ever seen again?) starts reading the preamble to the Constitution out loud, the girls all start obnoxiously cracking their gum.
Mr. Davis didn’t pay any attention to the unusual behavior, but Mr. Clark did. He frowned slightly and turned to the teacher just as Ross was getting to the part about “domestic tranquility.”
“Mr. Davis, do you allow students to chew gum in class?”
Mr. Davis appeared startled by the question. “Uh, no, of course not.” He looked at the girls, as if he was surprised to see them there. “Would you all please get rid of that gum?”
“But we just put it in our mouths!” Jessica yelled indignantly.
“Yeah!” called Ellen. “It hasn’t even lost the flavor yet!”
When Mr. Clark commands them to lose the gum, they all take it out of their mouths, put it in wrappers, and toss the wrappers on the floor.
Mr. Clark was aghast. “Girls! Pick those up!” He turned to Mr. Davis. “Do they always behave like this?”
Mr. Davis looked at him blankly. “Who?”
The girls continue to behave terribly, talking loudly about music videos and throwing pencils across the room, etc.
LOL. I’m sorry but Mr. Davis is such a loser, I can hardly stand it. And honestly, so is Mr. Clark. Excellent vetting process you have for hiring teachers, dude. He does, however, seem to notice that Mr. Davis is blatantly ignoring the girls and suggests he try to involve them in the discussion so they’re not bored.
Mr. Clark decides he’s seen enough. He pulls Mr. Davis into the hallway and tells him he’d better get his class under control or he’s going to be in serious trouble. Mr. Davis’ chance of redemption is the Sixth Grade Follies. He asks Tom how rehearsals are going, and Tom’s all like, huh, rehearsals, what?
Hahahaha.
Mr. Davis then tells the class that the Sweet Valley Town Council is considering remodeling the school and they have invited a representative body of students to come to their next meeting and give opinions. Elizabeth MIGHT have a chance to be on the committee—the students will be elected by their classmates. There’s only one problem: there are 10 boys and 10 girls in the class, and the divide Mr. Davis has caused means the boys will only vote for the boys, and the girls will only vote for the girls. And he, as the teacher, will cast the deciding vote in the event of a tie. We all know Mr. Davis will vote for one of the gerbils over one of the girls, so this is a problem.
That night, the twins almost tell Ned and Alice about Mr. Davis but they decide not to. Apparently they have a habit of complaining about teachers. Both of them? Not buying it, ghostie. But anyway, they keep quiet and devise a plan: Jessica will tell shy Ricky Capaldo that she’s going to nominate him for the committee, which will absolutely terrify him. Then Elizabeth will suggest that if he’s absent on the day of the election, he can’t be nominated.
Lo and behold, Ricky doesn’t show up the next day. Success! After a momentary scare when Lila is late (probably due to being awesome somewhere), the girls quietly celebrate—they have successfully tipped the boy/girl balance in their favor! Amy nominates Elizabeth. Elizabeth nominates Amy. The boys stay quiet, as none of them want to be involved because it = work. Elizabeth nominates Nora.
Mr. Davis glared at her with annoyance. He went back to the board, scrawled Nora’s name quickly, and looked at the boys, his eyes pleading.
“Boys, are you going to let this happen? This committee could affect everything that happens here at Sweet Valley Middle School. You could help the school get a bigger gym, or even a new science lab. Come on, boys! We need some men on that committee!”
HOLY ACTUAL WHAT THE FUCK IS GOING ON BALLS
Some of the boys finally nominate each other, but it doesn’t matter. Elizabeth, Amy, and Nora all win.
HA! TAKE THAT YOU SEXIST SCUMBAG.
That afternoon, the girls go watch the boys’ rehearsal for the Follies and it’s fucking terrible, as expected. Tom McKay has zero control and the boys are all running around the stage yelling things like, “Pow!” Desperate, he asks Elizabeth for help, and she quite awesomely is like, UM. NO. Tom then gets all mad and yells at her as if she didn’t just help him keep his brother from running away from home like 1 book ago.
The show is just as bad on the day of the Follies. The boys get booed and Mr. Davis gets in trouble. Mr. Clark wanted to know why none of the girls were involved and I’m guessing Mr. Davis didn’t say, “because I am a sexist piece of shit.”
It almost seems like he’s going to apologize to the girls, but then he confirms that they still aren’t allowed back on the softball team because it’s not a “suitable” activity for girls and the championship is at stake.
Some of the girls say they’re not even going to go to the game that afternoon but Elizabeth convinces them that they all have to show up, in uniform, and let everyone see that they are supposed to be on the team but Mr. Davis won’t let them play. I must say I agree whole-heartedly with Lizzie on this.
The game is hella boring. Then Jessica tells Janet Howell, 8th grade president of the Unicorns and most important girl at Sweet Valley Middle School, that they girls aren’t playing because Mr. Davis won’t let them. The message quickly spreads to everyone in the stands, and suddenly everyone’s shouting, “WE WANT THE GIRLS! WE WANT THE GIRLS!”
Mr. Davis is forced to let them play. Naturally, the girls kick ass. The game gets exciting and their team wins. And Mr. Davis is just like, dur, I didn’t know girls could do that. He explains that he used to teach in an all-boys school. That doesn’t explain anything, you twit. But he does agree to let the kids go back to their old seating arrangements and vows to try not to be such a sexist imbecile. So I guess that’s progress.
